Super Tuesday Rundown

March 6, 2020

This article originally appeared on BIPAC's blog. Written by BIPAC Political Analyst Jim Ellis.

Key Takeaways

  • Candidates Exit: Bloomberg, Buttigieg, Klobuchar, Warren, Steyer
  • Super Tuesday Results: Ex-VP Joe Biden has big night
  • AL-Sen: Ex-Sen. Jeff Sessions (R) forced to runoff
  • OK-Sen: Sen. Jim Inhofe (R) will seek re-election
  • CA: Many races still undecided
  • TX: Reps. Kay Granger (R) and Henry Cuellar (D) survive challenges
  • NC-Gov: Gov. Roy Cooper (D) vs. Lt. Gov. Dan Forest (R)

President

Super Tuesday Result:  Former Vice President Joe Biden won the lion’s share of Super Tuesday’s big delegate prize last night and took a major step toward winning the Democratic presidential nomination. Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) recorded a disappointing performance, placing first in only four states when polling suggested he might do so in nine. Mr. Biden topped the field in ten states, but scored majority support in only two, Alabama and Virginia.

According to an unofficial national delegate extrapolation from The Green Papers online elections site, Mr. Biden has approximately 677 delegates after Super Tuesday voting, with Sen. Sanders’ holding 604. The Biden total, if these numbers prove true, represent 46.6% of the available delegates suggesting he is well on his way to capturing a majority victory on the first ballot at the Democratic National Convention. We can expect further change in these delegate numbers when the final California numbers eventually become known.

The presidential campaign moves onto the March 10th voting, where individuals in six states, Idaho, Michigan, Mississippi, Missouri, North Dakota, and Washington, will next cast their ballots. Michigan, with 125 first ballot delegates, is the state where the candidates have the most to gain next Tuesday. On March 17th, the Arizona, Florida, Illinois, and Ohio primaries will take place. At that point, we should know if Mr. Biden will be able to clinch his first ballot victory.

South Carolina:  Former Vice President Joe Biden came through as needed on Saturday night in the South Carolina primary, revived his faltering campaign, and catapulted himself back into the front runner position. His 48-20-11-8-7-3% over Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT), billionaire Tom Steyer, ex-South Bend Mayor Pete Buttigieg, and Sens. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) and Amy Klobuchar (D-SC), sent a parade of candidates marching through the exits.

Candidates Withdraw:  Former New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg, after a poor Super Tuesday performance, ended his campaign and endorsed former Vice President Joe Biden. Mr. Bloomberg ends with 73 pledged first ballot delegates, just missing the qualification level in several big states that would have given him substantially more. He garnered over 14% of the statewide popular vote in both California (14.1%) and Texas (14.2%). To receive at-large delegates, a candidate must reach the 15% threshold.

Former South Bend Mayor Pete Buttigieg, who actually led the delegate count coming from both Iowa and New Hampshire, also exited the presidential campaign. In a speech to supporters yesterday back in Indiana, Mr. Buttigieg said, as the Associated Press reported, that “…we must recognize that at this point in the race, the best way to keep the faith with those goals and ideals is to step aside and help bring our party and country together.”

Minnesota Sen. Amy Klobuchar announced that she, too, suspended her presidential campaign on the eve of the major Super Tuesday voting. In her exiting remarks the Senator endorsed former Vice President Joe Biden.

Though billionaire candidate Tom Steyer finished third in South Carolina, his 11.3% of the popular vote was short of qualifying for delegate apportionment, meaning he had failed to get on the board after four presidential nomination events. Through the end of January, Mr. Steyer had spent over $253,000,000 on his race, with only $3.5 million coming from people other than himself.

Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) also made official her decision to suspend her campaign activities. The Senator says she will take some time to decide whether or not to endorse one of her competitors.

Senate

Alabama:  As expected, former US Attorney General and Alabama Senator Jeff Sessions qualified for the March 31st run-off election, but only finished second, one point behind retired Auburn University head football coach Tommy Tuberville. The secondary race winner faces Sen. Doug Jones (D) in the general election. Rep. Bradley Byrne (R-Mobile), who posted almost 27% of the vote, finished four points away from run-off position and is eliminated from further competition.

Massachusetts:  Suffolk University, polling for the Boston Globe newspaper, surveyed the Massachusetts Democratic electorate (2/26-3/1; 500 MA likely Democratic primary voters) and again found Sen. Ed Markey in difficult position against Rep. Joseph P. Kennedy III (D-Newton) for the upcoming Senate Democratic primary scheduled for September 1st. The results project Rep. Kennedy topping the veteran Massachusetts politician who was first elected to the state House of Representatives in 1972 and has been in public office ever since, 42-36%.

Montana:  For months, Gov. Steve Bullock (D) repeatedly stated he has no interest in running for the Senate, but apparently his position has changed. Gov. Bullock launched an ill-fated presidential campaign, and since its collapse Democratic officials including Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) have been attempting to recruit him to oppose first-term Sen. Steve Daines (R). Numerous media outlets are reporting that Bullock will announce his Senate bid on Monday, the deadline for candidate filing in Montana.

New Hampshire:  The University of New Hampshire released one of their Granite State polls, this time testing Sen. Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH) as she prepares to seek a third term. According to the UNH data (2/19-25; 611 NH adults; 576 likely NH general election voters), Sen. Shaheen’s closest potential Republican opponent is retired General Don Bolduc, but even he is far behind. The UNH Senate ballot test shows Sen. Shaheen easily outpacing Gen. Bolduc, 49-30%. Much time remains even before candidate filing, let alone the primary election. The New Hampshire candidate declaration period will end June 12th for their September 8th primary election.

North Carolina:  As expected, former state Senator Cal Cunningham easily captured the Democratic Senatorial nomination on Super Tuesday from the Tar Heel State. He topped state Sen. Erica Smith (D-Gaston), 57-35%, to advance into the general election against first term Senator Thom Tillis (R) in what will now be a long regular voting cycle. The Tillis-Cunningham race promises to be one of the top national US Senate races in November. This will be one of the key places that determines whether Republicans or Democrats will control the Senate in the next Congress.

Oklahoma:  When veteran Oklahoma Sen. Jim Inhofe (R) indicated that he would announce his future political plans in early March, most observers believed the 85-year old lawmaker would be announcing his retirement. Instead, it he declared late this week that he will seek re-election. Mr. Inhofe was first elected to the Senate in a 1994 special election. He previously served four terms in the US House, as Mayor of Tulsa, and in the Oklahoma Senate and House. Except for a four-year break in service, Mr. Inhofe has been in elective office since 1967.

Texas:  Non-profit organization executive Cristina Tzintzun Ramirez, who came within 1.3 percentage points of qualifying for the May 26th run-off election, conceded two days after the Super Tuesday vote to state Sen. Royce West (D-Dallas). Now, he and M.J. Hegar (D) advance to the secondary vote, the winner of that race to then challenge Sen. John Cornyn (R). The Senator, seeking his fourth term, will begin the general election cycle as a clear favorite for re-election.

House

Alabama Primaries:  The two contested open US House seats will advance to Republican runoffs with the winners becoming prohibitive favorites in the general election. Moving to the March 31st runoff elections are Mobile County Commissioner Jerry Carl and former state Sen. Bill Hightower in the 1st District, and businessman Jeff Coleman and former state Rep. Barry Moore in the Montgomery anchored 2nd District.

 

California:  According to the California Secretary of State, more than 780,000 ballots throughout the state’s 58 counties remain to be counted with more coming into election offices. Under California election law, voters may postmark their ballots on Election Day and be counted when they reach the intended office within three days of the vote. This election’s deadline is close of business today, March 6th. Therefore, it is probable that more than one million ballots will comprise the universe when the post-election counting period begins.

At this point, 32 of the state’s 53 congressional races do not officially have their two general election qualifiers. Under the California system, the top two candidates advance to the general election irrespective of political party affiliation or percentage of the vote obtained. We can expect the post-election counting process to take days, and likely several weeks before all of the totals become official.

NY-14:  New York City Councilman Fernando Cabrera announced this week that he is ending his Democratic primary congressional bid against noted freshman Rep. Alexandria Ocascio-Cortez (D-Bronx) and will instead run for Bronx Borough president. Upon his exit, however, Mr. Cabrera endorsed another Democratic opponent to the Congresswoman, former CNBC News anchor Michelle Caruso-Cabrera who is attacking Ms. Ocascio-Cortez from her right. Narrowing the field will help a strong challenger, but it is highly likely that the freshman House member will be nominated for a second term.

North Carolina Primaries:  The two open seats were basically decided on Super Tuesday. With Reps. George Holding (R-Raleigh) and Mark Walker (R-Greensboro) departing their now heavily Democratic districts because of the court-ordered redistricting ruling, former state Representative and 2016 US Senate candidate Deborah Ross and University of North Carolina at Greensboro Trustee Kathy Manning will easily win their respective general elections and join the next Congress in January.

Texas Primaries:  Rep. Kay Granger (R-Ft. Worth) was re-nominated on Super Tuesday with a hard fought 58-42% victory over former Colleyville City Councilman Chris Putnam. The Congresswoman will now have an easy run for a 13th term in the safely Republican seat.

Rep. Henry Cuellar (D-Laredo) was declared the winner over attorney Jessica Cisneros in the 28th CD, but the result was close, a 51.8 – 48.2% edge. Rep. Cuellar will now have an easy time in the general election and will win a ninth term in November from the safely Democratic South Texas seat.

Former congressional aide and ex-National Security Council official Austin Pfluger won outright the 11th District open Republican primary impressively over a multitude of candidates. He will easily win the general election from the Midland anchored district, one of the safest Republican seats in the country.

Run-offs are the order of the day in the rest of the contested races for one party or the other. Former Congressman Pete Sessions (R) did secure a run-off position in his new district, the Waco anchored 17th CD. He placed first but awaits the identity of his May 26th run-off opponent as the second position is too close to call. His likely opponent will be Renee Swann (R), endorsed by outgoing Congressman Bill Flores (R-Bryan/College Station), who is almost a percentage point ahead of businessman George Hindman, but it is still not certain that she will advance.

Governor

North Carolina:  Super Tuesday produced gubernatorial nominees in the Tar Heel State. Gov. Roy Cooper (D) was virtually unopposed for re-nomination, and Lt. Gov. Dan Forest was an easy winner on the Republican side. The two will now square off in what should be a hotly contested 2020 general election. Gov. Cooper will be favored for a second term, but North Carolina will be one of the hottest political states in the country from the top of the ticket to the bottom so this is a competitive contest.