Rep. Vicky Hartzler Leads in GOP Primary Poll; Redistricting Updates in MD, NY, OH

April 1, 2022

This article originally appeared on BIPAC's blog. Written by BIPAC Senior Political Analyst Jim Ellis.

Key Takeaways

  • MO-Sen: Rep. Vicky Hartzler (R) Leads in New Poll
  • OK-Sen: Rep. Markwayne Mullin Tops GOP Special Election Field
  • NC-Sen: Rep. Ted Budd Takes R Primary Lead
  • NE-1: Rep. Jeff Fortenberry (R) Convicted, Resigns from House
  • Redistricting: Court Decisions: MD; NY; OH
  • NY-Gov: Ex-Gov Not Ruling Out 2022 Return


Alabama: A new Emerson College survey (3/25-27; 687 AL likely Republican primary voters; live interview, interactive voice response, text & online) confirms what we saw from the Cygnal research group last week. That is, retired “Black Hawk Down” pilot and Alabama businessman Mike Durant leading former Business Council of Alabama president & CEO Katie Britt, with US Rep. Mo Brooks (R-Huntsville) falling well behind.

The new Emerson numbers find Durant ahead of Britt and Brooks, 33-23-12%. The previous Cygnal poll pegged the race at 35-28-16% in the same candidate order. Both studies suggest, at this point in time, that Mr. Durant and Ms. Britt will advance to a secondary runoff election. The Alabama primary is May 24th. If no one receives majority support, the top two finishers will advance to the August 23rd runoff election. Incumbent Sen. Richard Shelby (R) is retiring.

Alaska: The lone announced Democratic US Senate candidate, state Senator Elvi Gray-Jackson (D-Anchorage), issued a statement declaring that she is not going to enter the statewide race, and instead will seek re-election to the legislature. Ms. Gray-Jackson’s departure leaves the Democrats without a Senate candidate under a system where at least one Democrat would be all but certain to qualify for the general election under the state’s new top-four primary system. 

It was thought that 2020 nominee Al Gross who raised almost $20 million for his previous campaign against Sen. Dan Sullivan (R) would eventually enter the race, but he chose to join the at-large open US House special election field to replace the late Rep. Don Young (R-Ft. Yukon). The candidate filing deadline is June 1st for the August 16th regular primary election, so party officials have remaining time to recruit another candidate.

Louisiana: First-term Louisiana Senator John Kennedy (R) may only have to participate in one election this year if the trends found in a new poll are a true precursor. The JMC Analytics survey research organization released their new Louisiana study (3/21-23; 600 LA likely voters; live interview) and sees Sen. Kennedy holding 53% support with his closest competitor, 2021 special congressional candidate Gary Chambers (D), well behind at only 14%. 

Under Louisiana election law, if a candidate receives majority support in the jungle primary contest, which is run concurrently with the general election and this year on November 8th, the individual is declared the official winner and the campaign ends. If no one receives majority support, the top two finishers, regardless of political party affiliation, advance to a post-election runoff in December. This JMC survey suggests that Sen. Kennedy has a chance to claim a second term outright on November 8th.

Missouri: A new Trafalgar Group survey (3/24-29; 1,079 MO likely Republican primary voters; live interview, text, online panel) finds Missouri US Rep. Vicky Hartzler (R-Harrisonville/Columbia) forging into her first US Senate Republican primary campaign lead, as she tops former front runner Eric Greitens, the resigned Governor who now faces domestic and child abuse allegations from his ex-wife, Attorney General Eric Schmitt, and fellow US Rep. Billy Long (R-Springfield). 

The count breaks 25-24-22-8%, suggesting a tight August 2nd primary result. Since Mr. Greitens is already beginning to drop after the increased revelations about his personal history were made known, it is likely we will see his downward trend continue. The campaign evolving into a two-way race between Rep. Hartzler and AG Schmitt as we approach August is a distinct possibility.

North Carolina: A statewide North Carolina Republican primary survey finds US Rep. Ted Budd (R-Advance) overtaking ex-Gov. Pat McCrory as the two continue to pull away from the rest of the open GOP field. According to the Vitale & Associates survey (3/22-23; 504 NC likely Republican primary voters; live interview and interactive voice response system), Rep. Budd draws 32% support as compared to 29% for Mr. McCrory. Trailing well behind are former US Rep. Mark Walker and author Marjorie Eastman at 12 and 2%, respectively. The North Carolina primary, a prelude to one of the cycle’s most important Senate races, is scheduled for May 17th.

Oklahoma: In what is the first public survey offering testing the new Sooner State special US Senate election, we see that eastern Oklahoma US Rep. Markwayne Mullin (R-Westville) is the early front runner. 

The Amber Integrated survey organization conducted the statewide Oklahoma survey (3/24-27; 455 OK likely Republican primary voters; live interview) and found the Congressman posting 39% support, a full 25 points ahead of his closest challenger, former state House Speaker T. W. Shannon. Following in single digits are state Sen. Nathan Dahm (R-Broken Arrow), ex-congressional aide Luke Holland, who carries resigning Sen. Jim Inhofe’s (R) endorsement, and former National Security Council official Alex Gray. The poll finds the race breaking 39-14-6-2-1%, respectively, when adding those who support, or say they are leaning toward, a particular candidate.

Pennsylvania: Emerson College released their new statewide survey testing both the Democratic and Republican fields for the open Pennsylvania Senate race. According to the Emerson data (3/26-28; 1,069 PA registered voters; 471 likely Democratic primary voters; 372 likely Republican primary voters; interactive voice response system & online) Lt. Gov. John Fetterman continues to comfortably lead the Democratic primary with 33% preference, while Rep. Conor Lamb (D-Pittsburgh) drops back to just 10%, just ahead of state Rep. Malcolm Kenyatta (D-Philadelphia) who posts 8% support. 

Emerson finds the Republicans locked in a tie at the top with former hedge fund CEO Dave McCormick and television doctor Mehmet Oz deadlocked in first place. The two only have 14% support, apiece, however, still suggesting this is anyone’s race. Former US Ambassador Carla Sands, ex-congressional candidate and Trump campaign activist Kathy Barnette, and former Lt. Governor nominee Jeff Bartos all trail with 6, 6, and 5%, respectively. One possible reason for the low support identification figures for all the GOP candidates could be the low sample size for a large statewide primary electorate.

Utah: A Dan Jones & Associates poll for the Deseret News organization and the Hinckley Institute of Politics (3/9-21; 804 UT registered voters) finds Utah Sen. Mike Lee (R) holding what the pollsters term a “comfortable” lead of 43-19-11% over Independent Evan McMullin and Democrat Kael Weston. There was talk of Democrats trying to unite behind Mr. McMullin and not fielding a nominee of their own to avoid splitting the anti-Lee vote, so we will see if such a move transpires at the Utah Democratic nominating convention scheduled for April 23rd.


FL-20: New Florida Congresswoman Sheila Cherfilus-McCormick (D-Miramar) won her special election Democratic primary by just five votes over then-Broward County Commissioner Dale Holness. Former Broward County Commissioner Barbara Sharief finished third, some 3,000 votes behind the top two finishers. 

It appears we will see a one-on-one re-match between Rep. Cherfilus-McCormick and Mr. Holness. The latter has already announced his candidacy. Ms. Sharief, on the other hand, will launch a Democratic primary challenge to state Senate Minority Leader Lauren Book (D-Plantation), per her candidacy declaration within the last week. The 20th District Democratic primary, scheduled for August 23rd, will certainly be one to watch.

NE-1: A Los Angeles, CA jury convicted Nebraska US Rep. Jeff Fortenberry (R-Lincoln) of three felony counts late last week. The jury ruled he concealed illegal campaign funds from a foreign national, and for lying to federal investigators. At this time, the Congressman remains on the May 10th Nebraska primary ballot, but has announced that he will resign from the House on March 31st. Rep. Fortenberry says he will appeal the verdict. Since filing has closed, it is unclear as to whether the Congressman’s name will be removed from the primary ballot.

State Sen. Mike Flood (R-Norfolk) is the leading GOP candidate in Mr. Fortenberry’s absence. Retired Air Force officer John Glen Weaver, teacher Thireena Yuki, and welder Curtis Huffman round out the Republican congressional field. The consensus Democratic candidate is state Sen. Patty Pansing Brooks (D-Lincoln).

The FiveThirtyEight data organization rates the new NE-1 as R+17, down from R+21. Dave’s Redistricting App calculates an average Republican percentage at 56.3 as compared to the Democratic figure of 40.3%. A special election will be called to fill the balance of the term. Republicans, likely in the person of Mr. Flood, are clear favorites to hold the seat.


Maryland: The Maryland legislature is complying with a state judge’s schedule to return a new less partisan congressional map to the court. Senior Judge Lynne Battaglia last week struck down Maryland’s new congressional map as an “impermissible partisan gerrymander.”

The legislature’s new effort would restore Rep. Andy Harris’ (R-Cockeysville) Eastern Shore 1st District as safely Republican, while also making Rep. David Trone’s (D-Potomac) 6th CD less Democratic. Even the new map, if approved, would likely yield a 7D-1R delegation split, however. Despite the legislature’s compliance with the court, Maryland Attorney General Brian Frosh (D) announced late this week that the state will appeal the judge’s initial decision. Should a higher court overturn this district court ruling, the rejected map would then return.

New York: A New York district judge rejected the 22D-4R congressional map that the legislature and Governor passed under that grounds that the legislative branch did not have the power to assume district creation once the appointed commission members failed to produce maps at the stated deadline. For now, the judicial move invalidates one of the Democrats’ two best maps in the country. The judge ordered a new map must have “bipartisan support,” but did not define the phrase in terms of numbers of votes. The Democratic legislative leadership immediately pledged to appeal the ruling.

Ohio: It appears the legislature-passed congressional map will be used for the 2022 election. Last week the state Supreme Court indicated that it could not hear complaints against the new map because a final ruling was issued when rejecting the original plan. The court informed the Democratic plaintiffs that they would have to file a new lawsuit. They did so, but the briefing schedule has been set for a period two months after the state’s May 3rd primary. Therefore, the new congressional map looks to remain in place for 2022.  


New York: Resigned New York Governor Andrew Cuomo (D) has not yet ruled out trying to regain his position in this year’s election, and a new Siena College Research Institute poll (3/20-24; 804 NY registered voters; 309 Democratic primary voters) suggests that he might be competitive should he enter the race. 

The primary breaks only 38-30-10-7% in the Governor’s favor over Mr. Cuomo, US Rep. Tom Suozzi (D-Glen Cove), and NYC Public Advocate Jumaane Williams, respectively. While 41% of Democrats would either like to see Mr. Cuomo run for Governor as a Democrat (33%) or in the general election as an Independent (8%), a majority of 54% desires that he not run for Governor this year. Without Cuomo on the Democratic ballot, Gov. Hochul would lead Mr. Williams and Rep. Suozzi, 52-12-11%.