Ohio and Indiana Primary Results; NC and PA Senate Updates

May 6, 2022

This article originally appeared on BIPAC's blog. Written by BIPAC Senior Political Analyst Jim Ellis.

Key Takeaways

  • Primaries: Houchin, Vance, Ryan, DeWine, Whaley Win
  • NC-Sen: Rep. Ted Budd Cements GOP Primary Lead
  • PA-Sen: LG John Fetterman (D) Set; GOP Primary Unclear
  • NY-19: Rep. Antonio Delgado (D) Appointed Lt. Governor
  • Redistricting: Maps to be Finalized May 20th
  • GA-Gov: Gov. Brian Kemp (D) Establishes Strong Lead

Primaries - May 3rd Results

Indiana: The Hoosier State battle in Indiana’s southeastern corner to succeed retiring Rep. Trey Hollingsworth (R-Jeffersonville) ended as many predicted. There, resigned state Sen. Erin Houchin, a former congressional aide to ex-Sen. Dan Coats (R-IN), won the Republican primary, defeating former Congressman Mike Sodrel and Bronze Star medal winner Stu Barnes-Israel, 37-26-21%. Ms. Houchin now becomes the prohibitive favorite in the open 9th District general election. She will face educator Matthew Fyfe who won the Democratic primary but raised and spent less than $50,000 for his primary campaign.

In the northwestern 1st District, US Air Force Reserve Lt. Colonel Jennifer-Ruth Green easily defeated former La Porte Mayor Blair Milo, 47-22%, to capture the Republican nomination. She advances to face freshman Rep. Frank Mrvan (D-Highland/Gary) who is on the ballot for a second term. The Congressman was renominated in an 86% landslide.

Ohio: Best-selling author J.D. Vance, armed with an endorsement from former President Donald Trump, won the open Ohio US Senate Republican nomination last night with a 32-24-23% victory over former state Treasurer Josh Mandel and state Sen. Matt Dolan (R-Chagrin Falls). Businessman Mike Gibbons, who spent almost $17 million of his own money on the race, finished fourth with 12%, ahead of ex-Ohio Republican Party chair Jane Timken who posted only 6% support.

For the Democrats, as expected, US Rep. Tim Ryan (D-Warren/Youngstown) was an easy winner, capturing 70% of the Democratic vote from a turnout that was significantly lower than the party performance in the most recent 2018 midterm election. Thus, Messrs. Vance and Ryan now advance into what should be a competitive general election.

Incumbent Gov. Mike DeWine successfully won re-nomination for a second term, but with only 48% support. Had the anti-DeWine voters coalesced behind one candidate, it is now apparent that such an individual may have denied the Governor a primary victory. Former US Congressman Jim Renacci scored 28% of the vote and farmer Joe Blystone posted 22%. 

For the Democrats, Dayton Mayor Nan Whaley easily defeated former Cincinnati Mayor John Cranley with 65% of the vote. Ms. Whaley carried all but eight of the state’s 88 counties, including nipping Mr. Cranley in his home county of Hamilton. Whether Mayor Whaley can force Gov. DeWine into a tight November contest remains unclear, but she exhibited strength within her party while the Governor’s performance among Republicans was disappointing.

Primary turnout can often be a harbinger of what happens in a general election. In the Buckeye State, Republicans claimed the turnout war in impressive fashion even when considering the Democratic contests were not particularly competitive. Compared to the 2018 midterm election, Republican turnout was up 28%, with over 1 million voting. Conversely, Democratic participation was down 26% from their last midterm with an aggregate turnout total of just over 510,000 voters, literally half of the GOP figure.


North Carolina: A pair of new polls, one of which conducted for the North Carolina Chamber of Commerce, echo the findings of all other surveys released since March 22nd. That is, Rep. Ted Budd (R-Advance) is topping former Gov. Pat McCrory, US Rep. Mark Walker, and author Marjorie Eastman.  

In the NC Chamber poll, conducted through Atlantic Polling Strategies (4/25-28; released 5/4; 534 NC likely Republican primary voters; live interview and online), Rep. Budd is holding a 45-21-9-3% advantage. Meredith College (5/25-27; 1,225 adults; 588 NC likely Republican primary voters; online) posts the Budd margin at 33-26-7-3% in the same order as above. The North Carolina primary is May 17th. Rep. Budd has now led in eight consecutive polls.

Pennsylvania: Lancaster, Pennsylvania’s Franklin & Marshall College, featuring a frequent Keystone State polling entity, released their pre-primary data as a prelude to the May 17th statewide primary.  

For the Democrats, the survey (4/20-5/1; 792 PA registered; 357 Democrats, 325 Republicans, and 110 independents; live interview and online) projects Lt. Gov. John Fetterman to a strong lead, 53-14-4%, over US Rep. Conor Lamb (D-Pittsburgh) and state Rep. Malcolm Kenyatta (D-Philadelphia) according to this survey. 

The Republican side continues to be close with no candidate breaking away from the pack. The F&M results see Dr. Mehmet Oz barely leading the group with 18%, just two points ahead of former hedge fund CEO David McCormick. Trump campaign activist and 2020 congressional candidate Kathy Barnette follows with 12%, while former US Ambassador Carla Sands, and 2018 Lt. Governor nominee Jeff Bartos are at 5 and 2% support, respectively.


NY-19: Gov. Kathy Hochul (D) this week chose US Rep. Antonio Delgado (D-Rhinebeck) as her new Lt. Governor. Mr. Delgado replaces her first choice, Lt. Gov. Brian Benjamin (D), who was indicted for bribery and forced to resign. The selection of Rep. Delgado is an interesting one in that the appointment creates another vacancy in the US House and forces an additional special election. Currently, five House seats are vacant for various reasons.  

OH-7: Trump White House aide Max Miller (R), armed with the former President’s endorsement, easily won the Republican nomination since incumbent Rep. Bob Gibbs (R-Lakeville) surprisingly decided to retire after filing for re-election. Mr. Miller now becomes the heavy favorite to capture the R+14 open seat in the general election.

OH-9: In the Toledo anchored 9th District, Iraq War veteran and Trump campaign activist J.R. Majewski (R) claimed the Republican nomination in Tuesday’s election, defeating both state Rep. Craig Riedel (R-Defiance) and state Sen. Theresa Gavarone (R-Bowling Green). Mr. Majewski now advances into the general election against the Democratic US House member who has served longer than anyone in her party. Rep. Marcy Kaptur (D-Toledo) was first elected in 1982. The new 9th CD carries a R+6 rating.

OH-11: The Cleveland area hosted the most competitive Democratic congressional primary on Tuesday. Freshman Rep. Shontel Brown (D-Warrensville Heights/Cleveland) easily turned back former state Senator and 2020 Bernie Sanders for President campaign national co-chair Nina Turner by a landslide 66-34% margin. The two ran against each other in the 2021 special election that first elected Rep. Brown.

OH-13: Staying in the northern Ohio region, the new open 13th District that looks to be playing as an even political domain will feature a battle between state Rep. Emilia Sykes (D-Akron), who was unopposed in the Democratic primary, and TV commentator and former Miss Ohio in the USA beauty pageant, Michelle Gesiotto Gilbert. The latter woman captured the party nomination against six Republican opponents as another Trump endorsed Ohio candidate. The Sykes-Gilbert contest begins as a toss-up general election campaign.


New York: Steuben County Surrogate Court Judge Patrick McAllister, who first declared the New York congressional and state Senate maps illegal in reference to the New York constitution, now has the responsibility of drawing the new plans. He has appointed Dr. Jonathan Cervas of the Institute of Politics and Strategy at Carnegie Mellon University as the special master who will prepare the maps for judicial review. He was given a May 16th deadline to submit the plans, and the court has set May 20th as the date to finalize maps for the 2020 election cycle.  

Additionally, the judge moved the date of at least the congressional and state Senate primary from June 28th to August 23rd. The legislature now has the opportunity of moving the races not affected by the congressional and state Senate redistricting maps to join those now scheduled for August 23rd. If the legislators take no action, New York will have two primary dates this year.


Florida: A new St. Pete Polls survey (5/2-3; 1,859 FL likely Democratic primary voters; online) projects that US Congressman and former Governor Charlie Crist holds a dominating lead in the Democratic primary. The ballot test result finds Mr. Crist capturing 52% of the Democratic preference vote, way ahead of state Agriculture Commissioner Nikki Fried’s 19% and state Senator Annette Taddeo’s (D-Miami) 5% support.  

Georgia: Survey USA largely confirms the University of Georgia poll that found Gov. Brian Kemp (R) establishing a firm lead in his battle against former US Senator Davide Perdue who former President Donald Trump endorses. The S-USA poll (4/22-27; 2,000 GA adults; 1,587 GA registered voters; 559 GA likely Republican primary voters; online) posts Gov. Kemp to a strong 56-31% advantage, suggesting that he would win the Republican nomination outright on May 24th. Should all candidates be held under the majority mark, the top two would advance to a July 26th runoff election.  

The general election ballot test gave Gov. Kemp a 50-45% edge over former state House Minority Leader and 2018 gubernatorial nominee Stacey Abrams (D).

Hawaii: Former Honolulu Mayor Kirk Caldwell (D) announced yesterday that he is folding his gubernatorial campaign and will not submit documents at the June 7th candidate filing deadline. The Hawaii primary is August 13th. Mr. Caldwell sites lack of fundraising and organizational support for his decision to leave the race. Lt. Gov. Josh Green, US Rep. Kai Kahele (D-Hilo), and former First Lady Vicky Cayetano are the leading Democratic candidates. Republicans have 13 announced candidates, but the Democratic nomination will be tantamount to the election in November. Gov. David Ige (D) is ineligible to seek a third term.  

New York: A new Emerson College poll (5/1-3; 1,000 NY likely voters; 444 NY likely Democratic primary voters; combination interactive voice response system, text, and online) sees Gov. Kathy Hochul leading her Democratic primary opponents, Rep. Tom Suozzi (D-Glen Cove) and NYC Public Advocate Jumaane Williams, by a 45-12-7% count.  

More interesting, however, is the general election survey that includes former Gov. Andrew Cuomo running as an Independent. In this scenario, 33% would support a generic Democratic candidate, 33% a generic Republican candidate, while 16% would vote for Cuomo. There is no indication that the resigned Governor will enter the race. 

Pennsylvania: The above mentioned Franklin & Marshall College also released their pre-primary data for the Governor’s race. The results find state Sen. Doug Mastriano (R-Fayetteville), a retired Army Colonel, now leading the large group of Republican contenders with 20%, as ex-US Attorney Bill McSwain, and former US Rep. Lou Barletta follow with 13 and 12%. Attorney General Josh Shapiro is unopposed for the Democratic nomination. Gov. Tom Wolf (D) is ineligible to seek a third term.

Rhode Island: A Lake Research Partners survey for the Nellie Gorbea gubernatorial campaign was released (4/11-14; 600 RI likely Democratic primary voters; live interview) and the results project Rhode Island Gov. Dan McKee falling behind Secretary of State Gorbea as the candidates move toward the late September 13th Democratic primary. The ballot test posts Ms. Gorbea to a 30-24-10% edge over Gov. McKee and ex-Secretary of State Matt Brown. All other candidates fell below the 10% threshold. Gov. McKee ascended to his position in March when then-Gov. Gina Raimondo (D) became US Commerce Secretary.