Candidate Announcement Decisions Continue to Emerge

July 19, 2019

This article originally appeared on BIPAC's blog. Written by BIPAC Political Analyst Jim Ellis.

Key Takeaways

  • Presidential Polls: Kamala Harris up in CA; Joe Biden leads in MO; conflicting results in NH
  • Pete Buttigieg: leads Dem opponents in money race
  • IL-Sen: Sen. Dick Durbin (D) primary challenger out
  • TN-Sen: Amb. Bill Hagerty (R) to enter open race
  • CA-21: Ex-Rep. David Valadao (R) looking for re-match
  • NY-22: Ex-Rep. Claudia Tenney (R) may return
  • TX-21: Ex-Gov nominee Wendy Davis (D) to soon run for House
  • IN-Gov: Gov. Eric Holcomb (R) to seek re-election
  • VT-Gov: Gov. Phil Scott (R) draws Dem challenge

President

Pete Buttigieg:  South Bend Mayor Pete Buttigieg is topping his opponents in one category: money. Mr. Buttigieg raised over $24 million in the 2nd quarter, more than any other candidate including former Vice President Joe Biden who raked in $22 million. Sens. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) reported $19 million, while Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) posted $18 million, and Sen. Kamala Harris (D-CA) raised $12 million. Sen. Sanders, however, retains the most cash in his account, $27 million, with Mayor Buttigieg close behind at $23 million. Sens. Warren and Harris have more in the bank than they raised in Q2, $20 and $13 million, respectively. Here, it is Mr. Biden posting the most disappointing cash-on-hand figure at $11 million.

California Poll:  Quinnipiac University went to the Golden State, site of the March 3rd primary that will yield the largest first ballot delegate count in the country (416), in order to test Democratic preference (7/10-15; 1,125 CA registered voters; 519 likely Democratic primary voters). The results post home state Sen. Kamala Harris to a small, but significant, 23-21% edge over former Vice President Joe Biden with Sens. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) and Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) posting 18 and 16%, respectively. South Bend Mayor Pete Buttigieg falls back here with only 3% support.

Fox Poll:  The latest Fox News survey (7/7-10; 701 US likely Democratic primary voters) finds former VP Joe Biden commanding 35% support, back to his pre-June debate level, with Sens. Sanders and Harris posting the only other double-digit figures (14 and 12%, respectively). Here, Sen. Warren manages only 5% preference, just ahead of Sen. Cory Booker (D-NJ) and Mayor Buttigieg who record 3 and 2%, respectively.

MO Poll:  Bucking the latest trends that portray former Vice President Joe Biden's lead to be narrowing, Remington Research released what could be the first poll of Missouri Democratic voters (7/10-11; 1,122 MO likely Democratic voters through an interactive voice response system). Here, Mr. Biden continues to enjoy a strong lead, walloping Sens. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) and Kamala Harris (D-CA) 43-15-13%, and then destroying Mayor Pete Buttigieg and Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) who record just 5 and 4%, respectively.

NH Polls:  Last week, Change Research released polls from the early voting states including New Hampshire, which hosts the nation's first primary vote. Their original poll (6/29-7/4; 420 NH likely Democratic primary voters) found Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) leading Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA), Mayor Pete Buttigieg, ex-Vice President Joe Biden, and Sen. Kamala Harris (D-CA), 26-24-14-13-13%. But, Change went back into the field over the July 6-9 period with a much larger polling sample (1,084 NH likely Democratic primary voters) and found the Granite State race flip-flopping to Sen. Warren. In this study, it is Warren leading 22-20-19-15-13% over Sanders, Biden, Harris, and Buttigieg, respectively.

New Hampshire's St. Anselm College then released their new small-sample survey (7/10-12; 351 NH likely Democratic primary voters) and publishes a much different result. Anselm finds Mr. Biden topping the field at 21%, followed by Harris, Warren, Buttigieg and Sanders at 18-17-12-10%, respectively. It appears clear that we have a budding five-way race in this important early trend-setting state.

CNN then teamed up with the University of New Hampshire, sponsors of the sometimes-unreliable Granite State Poll (7/8-15; 386 NH likely Democratic primary voters), to release yet another survey of the New Hampshire Democratic electorate. According to CNN/UNH, former Vice President Joe Biden holds a 24-19-19-10-9% edge over Sens. Sanders and Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) who are tied, with South Bend Mayor Pete Buttigieg and Sen. Kamala Harris (D-CA) following. No other candidate even reaches the 3% support plateau.

Senate

Illinois:  State Rep. Anne Stava-Murray (D-Downers Grove) has closed her US Senate fundraising committee, thus already ending her Democratic primary challenge to Senate Minority Whip Dick Durbin virtually even before it began. Ms. Stava-Murray, in rather bizarre fashion, announced her challenge to Sen. Durbin right after she won her State Representative seat and before she was sworn into office. Thus, it is with little surprise that her Senate campaign gained no political legs.

Tennessee:  Now that former two-term Tennessee Gov. Bill Haslam and freshman Rep. Mark Green (R-Clarksville) will not pursue US Senate campaigns, speculation is building as to who might. Now expected to join the Republican Senate field is US Ambassador to Japan Bill Hagerty. The strongest GOP candidate in the race so far appears to be surgeon Manny Sethi. The top Democrat is attorney and Iraq War veteran James Mackler. Sen. Lamar Alexander (R) is retiring after three terms.

House

CA-16:   Last week, it was reported that Fresno City Councilwoman Esmeralda Soria was publicly considering launching a primary challenge to veteran Rep. Jim Costa (D-Fresno). Then, Ms. Soria followed through and announced that she will run for Congress. Rep. Costa, first elected to the House in 2004, has had two close general election campaigns, one in 2014 (50.7 - 49.3%) and another in 2010 in the former 20th District (51.7 - 48.3%), and only posted a 53-47% jungle primary result against GOP candidate Elizabeth Heng in 2018.

CA-21:  In 2018, after leading the vote counting until the very end when the outcome turned, former Rep. David Valadao (R-Hanford/Bakersfield) lost his seat to newcomer agri-businessman T.J. Cox (D). The total vote count of just 862 ballots separated the two candidates in what ended as the lowest turnout seat among California's 53 CDs (113,616 voters).

Late this week, Mr. Valadao, who has been quiet since the election, filed a 2020 candidate committee with the Federal Election Commission. While this does not constitute a statement of candidacy, it is a necessary first step. Reported sources close to the ex-Congressman indicate that Mr. Valadao will run and plans to formally announce in August. For his part, Rep. Cox just reported raising $708,501 through the second quarter with a cash-on-hand figure of $483,837.

CA-50:  Indicted San Diego/Orange County US Rep. Duncan Hunter (R-Alpine) has not yet gone to trial, but already five Republicans have announced their candidacies to replace him, all obviously anticipating there will be a special election early next year. The latest to join the field is investment consultant David Edick. The investor joins Mayors Matt Rahm and Bill Wells of Temecula and El Cajon, along with former Escondido Mayor Sam Abed. Retired Navy SEAL and ex-congressional candidate Larry Wilske is also in the race. Waiting in the wings are former 49th District US Rep. Darrell Issa and state Assembly Minority Leader Marie Waldron (R-Escondido) who are possible candidates.

FL-23:  Yet another Democratic incumbent is being challenged for the party nomination. At the end of last week, attorney Jennifer Perelman announced that she will oppose Florida Rep. Debbie Wasserman Schultz (D-Weston) in the 2020 Democratic primary. In 2016, law professor Tim Canova challenged Rep. Wasserman Schultz and, armed with presidential candidate Bernie Sanders' support, he raised just under $4 million for his campaign effort. Yet, even with his strong resources, Mr. Canova could do no better than hold Rep. Wasserman Schultz to a 57-43% Democratic primary victory.

MA-1:  Holyoke Mayor Alex Morse confirms that he is considering challenging House Ways & Means Committee chairman Richard Neal (D-Springfield) and will do so from the left. The Massachusetts state primary is not until September 15th after a May 5th candidate filing deadline, so Mayor Morse has plenty of time to make a decision. Holyoke is a city of only 40,000 people, but lies as part of the Springfield/Chicopee population anchor region.

NV-4:  Entrepreneur Lisa Song Sutton, who was Miss Nevada USA in 2014, announced that she will seek the Republican nomination to eventually challenge Rep. Steven Horsford (D-Las Vegas). Though the district leans Democratic, the campaign could become competitive.

NY-22:  Another of the nation's 2018 closest campaigns occurred in an upstate New York congressional district. In the state's 22nd CD, freshman Rep. Claudia Tenney (R) failed to win re-election by a scant 50.1 - 48.3% margin opposite then-state Assemblyman Anthony Brindisi (D). Now, it appears that she, too, will join those 2018 losing candidates who will return for another try. The 22nd District is the second strongest Trump CD (55-39%) in the US that a Democrat represents. With the President again expected to run well here in 2020, this promises to be a race to watch regardless if Ms. Tenney decides to run.

TX-21:  The Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee, House leadership, and most of the Democratic members of the Texas delegation are all lining up to sponsor an event next week to convince former gubernatorial nominee and ex-Ft. Worth state Senator Wendy Davis (D) to challenge freshman Rep. Chip Roy (R-Austin/San Antonio). It appears obvious that the die is cast for her to accept the support so expect Ms. Davis to declare her candidacy in conjunction with the event. Assuming she runs, the liberal Davis and conservative Roy would butt heads in a stark ideological contrast campaign.

WI-8:  Two-term Rep. Mike Gallagher (R-Green Bay), who has romped to 63 and 64% victories in 2016 and 2018, respectively, has drawn a significant Democratic challenger. State Assemblywoman Amanda Stuck (D-Appleton) announced that she will oppose the Congressman next year, but his strong performance in the northeastern Wisconsin CD suggests that she will have an uphill climb in making this contest competitive. President Trump carried WI-8 in the 2016 national campaign, 56-39%.

Governor

Indiana:  First term Gov. Eric Holcomb (R) made official this week what virtually everyone in Indiana expected: he will run for a second term next year. The Governor looks to have clear sailing in the Republican primary. At this point, former state Health Commissioner Woody Myers and state Sen. Eric Melton (D-Gary) are announced candidates. Former 2012 and 2016 gubernatorial nominee John Gregg is again a potential candidate. Gov. Holcomb looks to be in strong position for re-election.

Vermont:  Former Vermont Education Department Secretary Rebecca Holcombe (D) announced this week that she will challenge Gov. Phil Scott (R) next year. She becomes the first significant Democratic candidate to come forward. It is presumed Gov. Scott will seek a third term. Vermont, like neighboring New Hampshire, limits its Governors to two-year terms. Therefore, even though Gov. Scott will look to run for a third time, he will have only served four years once his current term ends.

Wisconsin:  Former Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker (R), who was defeated in seeking a third term last year, announced that he will become the President of the conservative Young America's Foundation in early 2021. This suggests the Governor will be active politically in the 2020 cycle but not return to Wisconsin for the 2022 election and likely beyond. His new operation is headquartered in Virginia.